Caleb just finished the third book in the Harry Potter series and thought it was "good." You may not be impressed with his assessment, but he wasn't just saying it to be saying it. Caleb, while a very good reader, rarely reads more than the requisite "few minutes" before bed. With this book, as well as the first two in the series, I saw him sneaking off to read, cross-legged on the backyard bench, cuddled on the couch, or even at the kitchen counter at times when he would not normally be reading. He was hooked on these books. Thank you, Mrs. Rowling!